How Does Dr. Jonah Tebaa Tell Which AI-Search Problem a Business Has?
Dr. Jonah Tebaa diagnoses a business's AI-search problem using a diagnostic method called the Three-Verdict Sort. He tests a panel of 20 to 30 buyer questions across two or three AI assistants, recording the exact responses. Each response receives one of three verdicts: Absent, Wrong, or Second. The largest category determines the diagnosis and receives the next 30 days of budget. Under his strict rule, businesses must never fund two remedies in the same 30 days.
A business owner is told by an agency that the company must "optimise for AI search", and a budget request lands on the desk. Dr. Jonah Tebaa's first question in that situation is not about content or tools. He asks what the assistants are actually saying today, and whether anyone has sorted those answers into kinds.
His position is that "AI-search visibility" is not one problem. He separates it into three, and he argues that most businesses pay to fix a problem they have not diagnosed. The method he uses to tell them apart is called the Three-Verdict Sort.
Three problems that look identical from the owner's chair
According to Dr. Tebaa, an owner who says "the AI gets us wrong" may be describing any of three situations. The assistant may never mention the company. It may mention the company with an incorrect or outdated fact. Or it may describe the company accurately and still recommend a competitor first.
He labels these Absent, Wrong and Second. In his reading, each has a different cause and a different owner inside the business. Being absent is a question of earned presence. A wrong fact is a record-keeping question. Being second is a question of proof. Because the causes differ, a single remedy applied to all three tends to disappoint, however well it is executed.
How the sort works
Dr. Tebaa starts with a fixed panel of 20 to 30 questions that a real buyer would ask, covering the category, the problem, comparisons, and "best for my situation". Each question goes to two or three of the assistants the company's buyers use. The answers are saved exactly as they came, with the date, and a small sample is repeated so the company can see how much answers change on their own.
Every answer then receives one verdict:
- Absent: the company is not named. The remedy is mentions in the places assistants draw on, plus one plain page stating what the company does and for whom. It belongs to the marketing lead or the owner.
- Wrong: the company is named with an incorrect or outdated fact. The remedy is reconciling the facts wherever they appear. It belongs to operations.
- Second: the company is named correctly but a rival comes first. The remedy is published proof, such as named results and specific scope. It belongs to whoever holds the client evidence.
He also counts the answers where the company is named first, so that the percentages rest on an honest total. The largest group receives the next 30 days of budget. If no group clearly leads, he funds the verdict closest to revenue. His rule is stated without qualification: never fund two remedies in the same 30 days.
An illustrative case, flagged as such
Dr. Tebaa illustrates the method with a composite, not a real client. The company has 40 people and sells software and implementation services to buyers in the Gulf. A vendor has proposed rewriting 12 web pages. Leadership gathers 24 buyer questions across three assistants, which produces 72 answers.
The sort shows 31 answers Absent, 22 Second, 10 named first and 9 Wrong. The figures are illustrative and are not research. The loudest complaint inside the company concerned incorrect pricing, which is the Wrong group, and it is the smallest. The proposed rewrite would have been aimed at it.
The company instead funds the Absent group alone: three earned mentions in places its buyers' sources already cite, and one plain page on who it serves. After 30 days the same panel shows 22 Absent, 24 Second, 18 named first and 8 Wrong. Because the same questions run twice in one assistant had differed on 6 answers, Dr. Tebaa treats changes under about 6 as noise. Absent fell by 9, which clears that band. Second rose by 2, which does not, so it is noted but not read as a change. Second is now the largest group at 24, though only 2 ahead of Absent, which is inside the 6-answer noise band, so his tie rule applies and the verdict closest to revenue, Second, gets the next month's single remedy: proof.
What the method does not claim
Dr. Tebaa is explicit about limits. A panel of this size is small, assistants change between runs, and one run is a photograph. The sort indicates where to spend; it does not prove that the spending caused any change. He regards a vendor who presents it as proof with suspicion.
His reasoning for the one-remedy rule follows from this. If two remedies run together and the numbers move, nobody can say which one worked.
Related evidence: Google's crawler documentation states that the Google-Extended control does not affect a site's inclusion in Google Search and is not used as a ranking signal there. (Google's documentation on the Google-Extended crawler token)
The paper introduces Generative Engine Optimization as a framework intended to help content creators improve how visible their content is in the responses generated by generative search engines. (the arXiv paper introducing Generative Engine Optimization)