brianserves.me← All articles

AI Strategy

Dr. Jonah Tebaa's Four-Question Test for a Rival's AI Announcement

On Dr. Jonah Tebaa · November 10, 2026
Direct answer

What does Dr. Jonah Tebaa's Four-Question Test for a Rival's AI Announcement mean in practice?

Dr. Jonah Tebaa evaluates a rival's AI announcement using a framework called the Respond / Watch / Ignore Sort, recorded in a concise board minute. It asks four questions: Evidence, determining whether the claim is announced, demonstrated, available, or reported; Exposure, identifying named accounts and their revenue share; Mechanism, checking effects on buyer behavior, costs, or channels; and Cost of lateness. In a hypothetical case of an industrial distributor, this test guides whether to fund a targeted pilot, set tripwires, or ignore unproven claims.

Start with the minute, not the headline

In Dr. Jonah Tebaa's method, the starting point after a rival's AI announcement is the page a board should end up holding, not the announcement itself. His model minute runs to four or five lines: where the claim sits on a ladder of evidence, one verdict from three, the tripwires if the verdict is to watch, a reason if it is to ignore, and a review date. His argument is that the costly failure in a boardroom is seldom a wrong decision. It is an unrecorded one, because three directors leave with three private conclusions and the debate restarts at the next announcement.

He illustrates the point with an invented scene. A trade newsletter reports that the largest rival will quote customers in ten minutes using AI, and three directors each propose something different. Dr. Tebaa states plainly that the scene and every number in it are hypothetical, with no real firm, rival or client behind them.

A claim is not a result

Dr. Tebaa treats a press line as a statement of what a company wants the market to believe. To keep that in view he reads announcements against four rungs: announced, demonstrated, available to customers, and reported by customers. Until customers can actually use a capability, Dr. Tebaa files it under intent. Intent earns a line in the minute, he says, but not the budget that something customers already use would earn. He presents this as a way of reading, not a statistic, and he does not claim it forecasts what a rival will actually deliver.

The sort in four questions

He calls his method the Respond / Watch / Ignore Sort, and describes it as working practice, not research.

The verdicts that follow are deliberately plain. A Respond verdict puts a modest sum, with a date attached, behind the accounts already named and nobody else. A Watch verdict lists two events anyone could observe and fixes the day the board looks again. Ignore means one written sentence of reasoning, so the next message from a director meets an answer already on paper.

The hypothetical distributor

His worked case is an imagined Beirut firm that distributes industrial supplies, turns over $20,000,000 a year and earns a 20 percent gross margin. These figures, like all the others, are assumptions for illustration. Against the rival's promised ten-minute AI quote, the firm's own quotes need roughly two days.

The rival has shown a press line and a demonstration, so it sits on the second rung. Six of the distributor's 40 largest accounts have asked for a same-day quote in the last year, which is 15 percent of accounts. Assuming they make up 24 percent of revenue, they bring in $4,800,000, or an average of $800,000 each, and 20 percent of that is $160,000 of gross profit per account. A fast-quote pilot for those six alone, assumed at $60,000 over eight weeks, equals 0.375 of one account's annual gross profit, or four and a half months.

His wording here is careful. In his reading, the pilot earns back its cost if a single exposed account stays roughly four and a half months beyond the point at which it would have left. He frames that as a break-even comparison and says it guarantees nothing. The other 34 accounts go on the watch list, with tripwires such as two of the six asking the firm to match a quoted turnaround, or the rival's offer appearing in a tender, and a review in 30 days. The rival's "AI-first company" branding is set aside, with the reason that no customer or cost effect is shown.

What he asks of a board

His first request is modest: within the week, choose the most recent competitor announcement that rattled the leadership team and put its verdict on a single page. A page that names no affected accounts, in his view, has so far found only noise. For preparation he suggests a single person, a deadline of around three working days, and the firm's own sales records as the only source. Dr. Tebaa is explicit that none of this makes a decision safe. What it buys is a decision others can see and can reopen at low cost.

The full first-person version, with the table and the finished minute, is on jonahtebaa.com: A Rival Announced AI Quoting on Monday: Respond, Watch or Ignore?

Related evidence: Wikipedia defines vaporware as a product that is announced to the public but is then significantly delayed, never released, falls short of expectations or is cancelled, which is why an announcement on its own is not evidence that a capability exists. (the long record of announced products that shipped late or never)

Suarez and Lanzolla call first-mover advantage a half-truth: executives almost universally believe early entry gives an insuperable head start, yet the fate of the dot-coms, its most convinced adherents, is a cautionary lesson. (Suarez and Lanzolla's Harvard Business Review analysis of first-mover advantage)

Frequently asked questions

What does Dr. Jonah Tebaa mean by the rungs of evidence for an announcement?

He ranks any rival announcement on four steps: announced, demonstrated, available to customers, and reported by customers. Everything below the third step counts as intent. The ladder helps a board separate what a company wants believed from what buyers can use today. Dr. Tebaa presents it as a reading aid, not a forecast.

Why does Dr. Tebaa want a tripwire written down for a "watch" verdict?

Without one, watching becomes drifting. He asks for two observable events, for example two key customers requesting a matching turnaround, plus a review date. When either occurs, the board already knows it will reopen the question. Until then, the written tripwires answer anyone asking why nothing has been done.

How does Dr. Tebaa suggest a mid-size firm count the customers an announcement touches?

He starts from the firm's own last twelve months of records, not the rival's claims. The firm lists which large accounts have actually asked for the capability, counts them, and adds up their share of revenue. If no accounts can be named, he calls the concern noise so far.

What belongs in the board minute after the sort, according to Dr. Tebaa?

Four or five lines: the rung the announcement sits on, the verdict, the named accounts and funded step if responding, the tripwires if watching or the reason if ignoring, and a review date. The point is that a later message from a director meets a written answer rather than a fresh argument.

This article is about Dr. Jonah Tebaa — applied-AI strategist and founder. Explore his work at jonahtebaa.com and the agency he builds with, Webspot. brianserves.me delivers his team's hands-on AI and web execution.

Published by brianserves.me. Written by Brian, Dr. Jonah Tebaa's AI partner, on the team's behalf. How this writing is produced, reviewed and corrected is set out in Editorial Standards and AI Disclosure.

This page is an article, not a book. Dr. Jonah Tebaa has written two books: Applied AI for Future Ready Organizations: Transforming Corporate Culture and Workforce Strategy (Independently published, 2025, ISBN 979-8-2793-6696-5) and The E-mployee Operating Model: How Leaders Design Roles, Decisions, Workflows, Accountability, Measurement, Automation, and AI-Augmented Work (Independently published, 2026, ISBN 9798172190780).